Choose a product
Generate a shortlist of 3–5 product ideas that align with your customer persona, then validate demand using trend data and marketplace research.
Why it matters
Stocking a product nobody wants is an expensive mistake, and an avoidable one. It is tempting to fall in love with an idea, buy inventory and only find out after launch that the demand was never there. Checking demand first costs an afternoon.
A good first product solves a specific problem for your persona, ships easily and leaves room in the price for ads, returns, platform fees and profit. If the margin is thin from the start, every later cost comes out of your pocket.
Think beyond a single product from day one. A yoga mat leads to blocks, straps, bags and cleaning sprays, and a customer who already trusts you is cheaper to sell to than a new one. Your first product gets you in the door. The range behind it is what brings people back.
How to do it
Score product ideas before you spend
1. Brainstorm 5-10 product ideas (20 min)
Using your customer persona, list products that solve their pain points. Browse Amazon bestseller lists, Etsy trending, and TikTok "Made Me Buy It" for inspiration.
- Search your niche subreddit for "recommendation" and "what should I buy" posts
- Check the Amazon Movers & Shakers page for rising products
- Don't filter yet. Just get ideas on paper
2. Score each product on four criteria (30 min)
Rate each idea 1-5 on these dimensions:
- Demand: Check Google Trends and Amazon search suggestions. A score of 5 means strong, rising demand with 1,000+ monthly searches.
- Margin: Can you sell it for 3-4x your landed cost (product + shipping to you)? A $10 product selling for $35-40 is the sweet spot. Below 2x, you can't afford ads.
- Shippability: Is it under 2 lbs, non-fragile, and fits in a standard mailer? Heavy or breakable products eat margins and create return headaches.
- Competition: Search Amazon. If page one is all listings with 5,000+ reviews, it's hard to break in. Look for niches where top sellers have under 500 reviews.
3. Validate the top 3 with data (30 min)
For your highest-scoring products, use Jungle Scout or Exploding Topics to check estimated monthly sales volume and competition level. Look for products with at least 1,000 monthly searches and competition below medium. Cross-check with Google Trends to confirm the trend is stable or growing, not a fad that has already peaked.
4. Check the expansion path (15 min)
For each finalist, list 5-10 related products you could add later. A product with no expansion path is a dead end. You want a gateway to a catalog, not a one-hit wonder.
5. Pick your winner (15 min)
Choose the product that scores highest overall AND excites you. You'll live with this product for months, so genuine interest matters. If two products tie, go with the one that has the clearest expansion path.
What you will have at the end
- A scored product validation spreadsheet rating demand, margin, shippability, and competition (1-5) for each idea
- Data-backed validation for your top 3 product ideas using Jungle Scout or Exploding Topics
- A product expansion roadmap showing 5-10 related future products for your winning pick
Tools for this step
Google TrendsFreeVisitSee whether demand for your product is rising or fading
Jungle ScoutFrom $49 a monthVisitEstimated Amazon sales and competition for a product idea
Exploding TopicsFree to browse, Pro from $39 a monthVisitProducts and niches growing before they peak
Tips
- Look for a complaint that keeps coming up in competitors' 3-star reviews (see Step 1). A product that fixes it starts with a selling point.
- Work out your true landed cost before you get excited: product cost, shipping to you, packaging, platform and payment fees, and an allowance for returns. If your selling price isn't at least 2.5 times that total, pick a different product.
- List 5-10 related products before committing to your first one. If you can't think of five, the product is probably a dead end.
Unlock the full course for free
Enter your email and we'll send you a code to unlock every step. It's free.
Our privacy policy says what we do with your email.